Brick couple find engagement ring, 9 years after it was lost in Italy
Nine years after losing their diamond engagement ring, Justin and Margaret Mussel found it in the most incredible fashion. Thomas P. Costello & Jerry Carino
Justin and Margaret Mussel returned from vacation with a remarkable souvenir.
Ever lose something valuable in the couch cushions, only to find it later? Well, Brick couple Justin and Margaret Mussel know the feeling.
Except the something they lost was a diamond engagement ring.
And they lost it in Italy.
And it was missing for nine years.
And they found it two weeks ago, not in the couch, but wedged into a crack on an Italian sidewalk.
Can’t believe it? Keep reading. It’s quite a story.
The Mussels were married in 2006. In the summer of 2008 they visited San Marco dei Cavoti, a southern Italian town where Margaret’s family owns a home.
“Earlier that day we had visited Pompeii and it was extremely hot,” Justin said. “My wife’s ring was loose, but she didn’t realize it was gone until later. She took a nap (after they returned to the house), and woke up and realized she didn’t have it on.”
A thorough search of the property came up empty, so they assumed it slipped off somewhere in Pompeii, gone forever.
“I felt terrible,” Margaret said.
The 1.1 karat, princess-cut diamond on a white gold band was covered under Justin’s renter’s insurance. Or so he thought. There was fine print, as he would learn later.
“If it was lost on international soil, not on U.S. soil, it wouldn’t be covered,” he said. “I did buy a replacement ring a couple of years later. Never in my wildest dreams did I ever think we would find it again.”
Fast-forward to this summer. Justin and Margaret, now 36 and parents to two boys, took the family back to San Marco dei Cavoti. They were seated on a bench in the front yard on the evening of Aug. 5 when something caught Justin’s attention: Every time a car drove by with headlights on, “I saw this flicker of light coming out of a crack in the sidewalk.”
He looked closer. The crack ran several inches deep. Curious, he grabbed a screwdriver from inside the house and dug in.
And there, nine years later, was the ring.
“The odds of it falling into this crack, much less finding it nine years later, are astronomical,” Justin said.
He called over to Margaret.
“I thought he was crazy,” she said. “I was like, ‘There’s no way the ring is in there.’ I couldn’t believe it. I thought he was playing a joke.”
Earlier in the day, she had stashed her replacement ring in the house; now she dashed in just to make sure it was still there.
It was. A quick comparison of the rings proved to them, without a doubt, that they had just stumbled onto a small miracle.
“When it fell off (in 2008), it must have bounced into the crack with the stone facing down,” Justin said. “It was covered in dirt, but there was just enough of the stone sticking out of it (to reflect the cars’ headlights).”
Margaret slipped it on. It still fit.
“The band is a little scuffed up, but not too bad,” she said. “The diamond looks good. If you saw it, you wouldn’t think it was in a crack for nine years.”
Diamonds are forever, after all.
So what of the rings now?
“I’d like to save the (newer) one for one of my boys, when it comes time for them to get married,” Margaret said.
The original is back where it started — on her finger. It has the most sentimental value, of course, and an awesome story to boot.
“I still can’t believe it,” she said. “I just keep looking at my hands.”
Staff writer Jerry Carino: email@example.com.